News / Nov 17, 2026
Progressives are Winning the Narrative Contest over Rigged Systems. We Can’t Stop Now.
After years of hesitating, progressives are finally speaking to Americans’ shared experience that “the system is rigged.” They’re embracing rigged system narratives that highlight how systems are rigged to benefit the powerful few at the expense of the rest of us, and are calling for action to unrig those systems.
It’s critical not to abandon this narrative just as it is starting to work.
The narrative that “the system is rigged” has been part of mainstream politics throughout the past decade, but until recently, progressives ceded this narrative to the right, who painted a dark picture of liberal elites and the deep state rigging the system in favor of “illegal” immigrants and against hardworking (white) Americans. In the past couple of years, progressives have finally countered this exclusionary and authoritarian narrative by embracing their own, alternative version of a rigged system narrative, with powerful effects.
By acknowledging that the system is rigged against most Americans and providing an alternative narrative about how, progressives have countered the right’s anti-immigrant, authoritarian story, placed the focus on how our systems concentrate power in the hands of a small economic and political elite, and mobilized Americans to take back power.
In the wake of the midterms, the advocacy and organizing context has changed, but the importance of speaking to people’s experience that the system is rigged against them is now more vital, not less.
With increased power in Congress, it’s tempting for progressives to abandon the rigged system narrative, to drop the broader social critique and narrow the focus to short-term policy fixes that would help with affordability and people’s other day-to-day concerns. This would be a tremendous misstep.
The MAGA right claimed the narrative while progressives shied away
To understand why this would be a mistake, we have to examine the broader arc of rigged system narratives over the past decade. In 2016, a few influential political actors on the left were using the narrative, including Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, and SEIU, but most progressive and liberal advocates and politicians were wary of talking about rigged systems. While some may have rejected this narrative because they didn’t actually think systems were rigged, others were clearly sympathetic to the idea but worried that talking about rigged systems would foster cynicism and undermine faith in the idea that the government can be trusted to provide for people’s needs.
Meanwhile, the MAGA right wholeheartedly embraced a rigged system narrative. Their version pointed the finger at liberal political and cultural elites, claiming they were rigging the system in favor of “illegal” immigrants and people of color at the expense of good, hardworking (white) Americans. This narrative paired an appeal to a genuinely widespread feeling that systems don’t work for people with an appeal to dominant groups’ experience of their status being threatened by social changes ranging from the first Black president and rising immigration to the #MeToo movement and the Movement for Black Lives.
In 2022, FrameWorks began an ongoing effort to help progressives reclaim the rigged system narrative. Our research had convinced us that this was the critical cultural contest of our time—and progressives were refusing to engage in it.
Why we couldn’t afford to ignore the system-is-rigged mindset
Since 2020, the FrameWorks Institute’s Culture Change Project has explored how Americans’ assumptions about the world—our cultural mindsets—are evolving in our current period of social upheaval. In early focus groups, we quickly saw that Americans across groups—political party, race, gender, age, and income—were drawing on the system-is-rigged mindset over and over again to make sense of everything that was happening in society. While people applied this thinking in different ways, they shared the assumption that in the United States, the system is rigged to benefit the powerful few at the expense of most people.
It was clear to us that ignoring this mindset was a huge mistake, for two reasons. First, this way of thinking creates unique openings and dangers. It opens space for thinking about systems and power in ways that have the potential to build demand for transformative structural change. But it can also be hijacked to fuel exclusion and domination. The only way to steer into the openings and avoid the dangers is to engage. Second, given how dominant this assumption was, people were going to draw on this mindset no matter what. Refusing to engage with it effectively ceded this powerful and deeply motivating way of thinking to the right.
Since 2022, FrameWorks has conducted research to identify effective ways of talking about rigged systems. Through ongoing focus groups, one-on-one interviews, and experimental surveys, we deeply examined the system-is-rigged mindset and then tested different versions of rigged systems narratives. Through this iterative research, conducted in close partnership with organizations working across fields and movements, we crafted a highly effective, progressive version of the rigged system narrative that:
- Speaks to people’s deeply felt experience,
- Channels system-is-rigged thinking in the direction of justice and democracy while preventing it from being used to stoke xenophobia, racism, and authoritarianism, and
- Combats fatalism by building collective efficacy and agency.
Making the case for a progressive counter narrative
Some of our partners were understandably worried that talking about the system being rigged might bring to mind MAGA narratives and activate the regressive and exclusionary thinking these narratives foster. When we began research in 2022, the hope was that the country could rebound from MAGA and the pandemic and deliver on what Americans wanted and needed from the government. A rigged system narrative was antithetical to the “deliverism” that was in fashion at the moment—the idea that the key to retaining power was enacting policies that deliver concrete benefits and address people’s immediate economic needs.
Our research was telling us that trying to steer clear of the system-is-rigged mindset was a mistake. In our mindset survey, we track responses to the question, “Do you think the system is rigged in America,” and we have found over the past several years that around 70% of Americans consistently say “yes” to this statement, with majorities of almost every demographic and ideological group agreeing.
The idea that the system is rigged wasn’t an ephemeral one, tied to a particular administration or moment, but a deeply held assumption grounded in people’s very real experiences.
People consistently experience systems that are in fact designed to work for the powerful few but not for them. From a gig economy where they’re at the whim of companies, to being subjected to new technologies over which they have no say, to a healthcare system that is unresponsive and overly expensive, to Supreme Court decisions like Dobbs v. Jackson that fly in the face of what people want, Americans experience systems that are rigged against them every day.
Through continued research over the past five years, we have found that variations of the rigged system narrative work across issues. Because the mindset creates both openings and dangers, it’s critical that we clearly name who actually benefits from rigged systems and who is harmed by them and that we explain how systems are rigged and—perhaps most importantly—can be unrigged. By telling the right kind of rigged system stories, we can build demand for and belief in the possibility of the transformative changes needed to realize justice and democracy in our society. Working closely with field partners, including multiple advisory boards and core partners like Democracy Revival Center, Liberation in a Generation, and SEIU, we conducted testing through focus groups and experimental surveys on particular issues, finding that specific versions of the narrative build demand for transformative change and a sense of efficacy and agency on issues ranging from economic and labor justice and tax reform to democracy and racial justice.
As we reached beyond close partners and shared findings with wider fields, we saw a gradual softening of earlier resistance to using the rigged system narrative. Over time, as we were able to better answer questions and concerns about the narrative and as it became harder and harder to ignore the depth of people’s dissatisfaction with the status quo, we found more and more leaders and organizations were willing to take up and use this narrative through their channels, with their audiences, and to advance their goals.
From skepticism to widespread adoption
In 2025, the tide began to turn toward a widespread embrace of the rigged system narrative among progressives. Progressives were on the outside of government, so a rigged system narrative felt natural and easier to embrace. Moreover, Americans’ frustration with the status quo was palpable. It was clear that speaking to Americans’ desire for major change to our current systems was critical.
The rigged system narrative spread through many organizations’ efforts. In our own network, core partners like Democracy Revival Center and Liberation in a Generation disseminated and socialized the narrative in their fields. Other organizations we know and respect have done research to develop their own versions of the narrative, for their specific audiences and purposes, from RadComms’ outside campaign with Rising Majority to Groundwork Action’s inside efforts on economic policy.
We are now seeing skillful and creative uses of the rigged system narrative from progressive leaders, including in the midterms themselves. The narrative has taken on a life of its own. As a nonpartisan nonprofit, FrameWorks doesn’t work with candidates, but we watched with interest as the narrative was widely taken up. These appeals tapped into the deeper undercurrents beneath anti-incumbent and anti-establishment sentiment. By turning to the rigged system narrative, candidates recognized that Americans didn’t simply disagree with policy choices or government decisions, but felt shut out of power across systems in our society, including the political system.
The narrative is being adapted for different contexts, audiences, and even political perspectives. It is being used by leftists, who have a history of embracing the narrative, but is also being adopted by center-left leaders who are pro-capitalist but are speaking to the oligarchical and undemocratic nature of power in American society today. It takes a different form in Texas than in Michigan, but its power and effectiveness is apparent across the ways and places it’s being used.
If we want to see real change, now isn’t the time to let up
The midterms have changed the context for progressive advocacy and organizing, but it’s critical not to abandon an effective rigged system narrative as it’s gaining momentum and boosting demand for changes many of us wouldn’t have thought possible a decade ago. In a moment when progressive policies can take center stage on the floor of Congress, it’s tempting to drop the broader critique of systems and narrow the focus to policies that address immediate needs, like lowering the price of gas and ending the war in Iran. This would be a major mistake.
Americans’ experience that the system is rigged against them runs deeper than the balance of power in Washington at any given moment. The belief and feeling that the system is rigged has not disappeared due to the election, and thinking it has misunderstands the deep cultural undercurrents of the period we are in. It isn’t merely the result of policies that have failed to control the cost of living or of an unpopular war. Until people see real changes to systems themselves—until they see fundamental shifts in who holds power within our society and how our economy and our political system work—–this mindset will continue to animate the US public. That means we need to continue engaging with this mindset and addressing people’s desire not merely for better policies on specific issues but for unrigging the system itself.
We know the elements of effective system-is-rigged narratives and they remain as critical now as ever:
- Appeal to values that center collective power.
- Explain how the system is rigged, not just who is rigging it.
- Match the scale of the solution with the scale of the problem.
A rigged system narrative can be used to build demand for major changes to the political system, build power to counter racial injustice and economic exploitation at the community level, highlight the value of worker power, build demand for systemic changes to work and the economy, and cultivate widespread understanding of racism as a rigged system. This narrative is key to advancing justice and democracy in the coming years.
The final element of the narrative—matching the scale of the solution to the scale of the problem—is especially important in the current context. People experience rigged systems as a massive problem, and they want to see major changes to our economic and political systems. As progressives navigate a new context in Washington, it’s critical to keep this desire for fundamental system change in view, even if many changes aren’t possible in a moment of divided government. Our research shows that, paired with an effective rigged system narrative, big, bold solutions are highly motivating and build belief in the possibility of change.
Progressives shouldn’t constrain their narratives to what seems feasible in Washington in the current moment. While they can and should talk about what can be accomplished now, they must also continue to speak to people’s larger sense that our society is tilted against them and show people what unrigging it would involve.
By continuing to use a rigged system narrative, we can highlight that the fight can’t be won through a single election, but involves a deeper, longer-term contest to change how our society works in the most fundamental ways.
Situating current fights in this broader context can prevent people from becoming disillusioned when short-term results don’t match their hopes. And by continuing to speak to the need to unrig the system and to the types of changes that are ultimately needed to accomplish this, we can lay the groundwork for bigger demands in the future.
Progressives have made tremendous progress in claiming the critical cultural terrain of the system-is-rigged mindset. We are winning this contest. What we cannot do now is take our foot off the gas. If we do, exclusionary and authoritarian forces will reclaim the ground we have fought so hard to take back, and the progress we see now will disappear.
Issues: Government and Democracy
Countries: United States